A decent episode, but the last 2 episodes didn't live up to the hype. Karl and Danielle as the deaths they were talking about? Lame......
I gave it an 8 all the same, not too much additional info we found out in this one, just Michael's backstory which was interesting but nothing earth shattering. I'm sure he's the one in the coffin now, and his assumed identity while in Manhattan is John La(n)tham.
I gave it a 6, I'll up it later on, depending upon how the situations develop. Danielle isn't dead, she is just 'mostly' dead. This was a on the edge of your seat episode, but, we saw it a mile away they needed to explain Michael, so ho hum, he'll do anything for WAAAAALLLLLTTTT. Boring.......
I gave it a solid 8. I would probably have given it an 8.5 though if that had been an option. I thought that it was a really good episode and it actually made me forgive Micheal--at least a little bit anyway.
It was great to see Libby again, but I was really surprised that Micheal didn't listen to her. And it was really interesting to find out that those who leave the island become invincible--at least until the island is done with them. But I still think that Micheal is the one in the coffin in TTLG.
BTW--I really wasn't looking forward to this episode as I already knew it would be Micheal centric and I've never been a big Micheal fan, but I was pleasantly surprised to find it much more interesting than I had anticipated.
I gave it a 7. It wasn't bad but I expected something a little more exciting regarding Michael's story. I think they definitely could've written the whole part when he's in NY better. Glad there's a gay character on Lost
Another great episode! I gave it a 9. I would have given it a 10 but I would have liked to have learned how Michael and Walt made it back to the mainland. Did the Others help out or did they get picked up by a shipping boat. Small nitpick since it will probably be explained later. Other than that I loved it and the preview for the next one gave me chills! Plus, I don't think Danielle is dead
Foxy's Man Giggles | TEAM JACK!| 
and
and 