A decent episode, but the last 2 episodes didn't live up to the hype. Karl and Danielle as the deaths they were talking about? Lame......
I gave it an 8 all the same, not too much additional info we found out in this one, just Michael's backstory which was interesting but nothing earth shattering. I'm sure he's the one in the coffin now, and his assumed identity while in Manhattan is John La(n)tham.
Wouldnt have been lame if you hadn't heard about it. Anyways, 8 or 9, I cant decide.
"...Jack and Sawyer. They're the duality. They're one of the most important character axes on the show."
I gave it a 5, It was meh for me. The whole death fake out thing is getting old and not really anything new learned or progression made. Just average. Sorry, Mike, I guessed it was blackmail all along.
Solid eight. Seemed to drag on a little at the NY parts, but the ending I liked. It reminded me of season one when you knew something was in the jungle, but you didn't know what, great cliffhanger.
Gave it a 9. Agree with Shyguy's order - this one was great but not as good as The Constant! I hope Danielle is not dead. This epi explained tons & confirmed a lot of other info. Thank You writers!!!!
I'm so glad this episode aired before the break. I gave it a 10 for a riveting story that had bizarre scene after bizarre scene. Great to see so many Lost characters woven into the story, even though it was Michael-centric and Michael-heavy. I really enjoyed seeing Harold back on the screen in a big way. Just too much good stuff to mention here. For me, Season 4 has delivered 7 good episodes. Good job to all those involved in the making of Lost.
Gave it a 10 really enjoyed it and can't wait for more. Its nice to know part of what happened to him after he escaped. This and The Constant are up there in my list of favorite episodes so far.
and
and 